30 March 2006

Question: LC in parallel

How to calculate the resistance of a capacitor and an inductor connected in parallel?
(-XcXL/(XL-Xc))^2 ?



This is a little bit trickier that considering elements in series because the inverse of the impedances have to be added. I'm pretty sure it is beyond the scope of this course to need to do this calculation, but I will put it here anyway. I'm also not sure how you would arrive at the answer without using the appropriate complex represenations of the impedance, so I will use them but try to be careful to explain.

So, for elements in parallel:

1/Ztot=1/ZC+ 1/ZL+ 1/ZR ...[1]

We will consider just an LC circuit (with ideal components), so R=0. Now, in complex notation ZCand ZL are:

ZC=1/iωC ...[2]
ZL=iωL ...[3]

So substituting [2,3] into [1]:

1/Ztot=iωC+1/iωL

or, using the fact that 1/i=-i:

1/Ztot=iωC-i/ωL
1/Ztot=i(ωC-1/ωL) ...[4]

so, we can now replace 1/ωC with XC and ωL with XL:

1/Ztot=i(1/XC-1/XL) ...[5]

Now we can simplify the part in the brackets, giving us:

1/Ztot=i(XL-XC)/XCXL ...[6]

or taking the inverse of the fraction on both sides (and once again using 1/i=-i):

Ztot=-iXCXL/(XL-XC) ...[7]

Now, if we had also had a resistor in parallel in the circuit (R), we would end up at equation [7] with both real and imaginary parts. To find Xtot we would have to find the magnitude of the resultant phasor. Since Ztot is purely imaginary, we need only to find the magnitude of this number, which we can express as:

Xtot=-XCXL/(XL-XC) ...[8]

Which is pretty much what I think you suggested. Note that if we hadn't used the imaginary numbers we would not have been able to get the right signs and would have come up with a different answer.

Looking back at eqn. [7], let's think about what this represents... In the imaginary plane Ztot would be a phasor pointing along the y-axis. For values of XL and XC which make Ztot positive, the impedance could be considered "inductive", and inversely if Ztot were negative, the impedance could be considered "capacitive".

Let's consider two extreme cases...

If the frequency is high, XL is very large, and XC is very small (let's say negligible). In the numerator of Ztot the frequency cancels out, so this is a constant. If we look at the denomenator, XL >> XC, so the denomenator is approximately XL. Since XL is large, Ztot will be small and negative (capacitive). In fact if you substitute in equations [2,3] ignoring XC in the denominator, you will recover ZC. This is consistant with the inductor providing a break in the circuit, and the capacitor providing a short.

Similarly, if the frequency is very low, XC becomes very large, and XL very small. In this case, the result is small and positive (inductive), and indeed again, if you work it out you will recover ZL as Ztot. This is consistant with the capacitor providing a break in the circuit, and the inductor providing a short.

To summarize:

ω→∞ Ztot→ZC and current flows through the capacitor
ω→0 Ztot→ZL and current flows through the inductor

These limiting cases can be worked out simply as a thought experiment (consider which branch of the circuit has a small resistance and which has a large resistance) and are often more insightful than getting through the algebra.

Hope this helps.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

wow, that helped a lot, it was the question come from the last lab. Actually I didnt need to calculte the resistance, but I was curious about how to get the resistance:) You are right, it's way beyond this course, especially the "j" part, really hard for me to accept..but, anyway, I got the idea, thanks a lot.